Manchester City secured a 2-0 first-leg lead over Newcastle in the Carabao Cup semi-final, but the match was defined by a controversial VAR decision.1 New signing Antoine Semenyo saw a goal disallowed after a nearly six-minute review involving Erling Haaland, sparking fury from Pep Guardiola and City’s senior stars.
Manchester City took a significant step toward the Carabao Cup final with a 2-0 victory at St James' Park. However, the talk of the football world is the 63rd-minute disallowed goal. Antoine Semenyo, City’s £65m January arrival, thought he had scored his second of the night, only for a 5-minute and 40-second VAR check to rule it out. Referee Chris Kavanagh eventually determined that Erling Haaland, in an offside position, interfered with Newcastle’s Malick Thiaw.
Technology Failure The controversy was compounded by a failure of the semi-automated offside technology. Because players were too close together, VAR Stuart Attwell had to manually draw lines—a process that has been widely criticized for its length and "anti-goal" nature. While experts like Jamie Redknapp and Dan Burn admitted the call was technically correct by the "letter of the law," others, including Micah Richards and Chris Sutton, labeled it "re-refereeing" and a "sheer guess."
Guardiola and Silva’s Frustration Post-match, Pep Guardiola was visibly frustrated, citing a pattern of inconsistent decisions against his side at St James' Park. He referenced previous denied penalties for Phil Foden and Jeremy Doku, stating he expects an explanatory call from PGMOL’s Howard Webb. Captain Bernardo Silva echoed these sentiments, noting that City is "getting used to" such disruptions.
Semenyo’s Impact and City’s Squad Depth Despite the disallowed goal, Semenyo’s arrival from Bournemouth has immediately bolstered City’s attack. With 10 goals this season, he provides a vital alternative to Erling Haaland, who is currently in a "sticky patch" with only one goal in his last six games. The Ghanaian's versatility may lead to January exits for fringe players like Oscar Bobb or Savinho, as City looks to close the six-point gap behind Arsenal in the Premier League.
While City celebrates their new recruit, Bournemouth continues its strategy of high-profit sales, having netted roughly £250m since the summer. Conversely, Manchester United remains the "loser" of the window, having missed out on Semenyo amid the sacking of Ruben Amorim and the interim appointment of Michael Carrick.
