Long before becoming a World Cup hero, Argentine goalkeeper Emiliano "Dibu" Martínez had a knack for irritating his opponents. As a child playing youth tournaments in Mar del Plata, if he felt untested, he would deliberately give up rebounds just to force rival attackers into taking more shots.
"He was already known for talking a lot," his first coach, Jorge Peta, recently revealed.
Today, that provocative temperament has made Martínez one of the most polarizing figures in modern football. While his spectacular late save against France’s Randal Kolo Muani at Qatar 2022 cemented his status as a national hero, his psychological mind games during penalty shootouts have drawn heavy criticism from global football legends.
Icons like Fabio Capello, Edwin van der Sar, and French World Cup winner Emmanuel Petit have publicly criticized his antics, with Petit even suggesting the Aston Villa goalkeeper needs help controlling his emotions. Furthermore, his strategy of distracting penalty-takers directly prompted FIFA to enact a strict new code of conduct, effectively banning goalkeepers from using delaying tactics, speaking to, or gesturing at penalty-kickers. In 2024, FIFA even handed Martínez a two-match suspension for offensive behavior during South American qualifiers.
Yet, the 33-year-old remain completely unfazed by his detractors.
"What people think doesn’t affect me," Martínez said in a recent interview. "Off the field, I’m a dad, a husband, a son. But on the field, I just want to win, nothing else."
Martínez’s rise to global fame is remarkable given his unconventional path. He left Argentina as a teenager for Arsenal without ever playing in the domestic first division. He spent years loaned out to lower-tier English clubs like Oxford, Sheffield Wednesday, Rotherham, and Reading before national team coach Lionel Scaloni handed him his senior debut in June 2021.
From that moment, the Argentine goal belonged to him. His psychological mastery took center stage during the 2021 Copa América semifinal when he taunted Colombia's Davinson Sánchez with the now-famous line, "I am sorry, but I will stop you, bro," before saving three penalties. He repeated these antics in the "Battle of Lusail" shootout against the Netherlands, and again in the legendary Qatar final, where his mind games forced France’s Aurélien Tchouaméni to shoot wide.
Despite the continuous friction with football authorities, Scaloni has locked Martínez in as Argentina’s starting goalkeeper for the upcoming World Cup in North America. Martínez enters the tournament firmly established at Aston Villa, fresh off a historic Europa League title win.
Though he fractured the ring finger on his right hand during the Europa League final against Freiburg, medical staff confirm he will be fully fit for Argentina's Group J opener against Algeria on June 16.
"Everything else is part of his personality," Scaloni said, brushing aside the controversy. "We focus strictly on the sporting aspect."
To the Argentine public, Martínez is irreplaceable. Ahead of the World Cup, his No. 23 shirt is the country's most sought-after piece of merchandise alongside Lionel Messi’s iconic No. 10. For Martínez, his greatest pride is the cultural shift he has created back home: "The most important thing we take away from this is that the love for goalkeeping has returned."
